From 3c90d33b9d1b6cc70fa63f8b3cdcf3753bee3d1c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Pieter Vander Vennet Date: Sun, 17 Nov 2024 22:55:19 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] Docs: blogpost reviewing the image move --- Docs/Reasonings/ImageGraph.png | Bin 0 -> 23807 bytes Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramax.md | 78 ++++++++++++++++++++++++ Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramaxAll.png | Bin 0 -> 24927 bytes Docs/Reasonings/PanoramaxGraphSmall.png | Bin 0 -> 15315 bytes 4 files changed, 78 insertions(+) create mode 100644 Docs/Reasonings/ImageGraph.png create mode 100644 Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramax.md create mode 100644 Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramaxAll.png create mode 100644 Docs/Reasonings/PanoramaxGraphSmall.png diff --git a/Docs/Reasonings/ImageGraph.png b/Docs/Reasonings/ImageGraph.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..13e1f0431ec1cbde0ac3ded6ae1b01ce073d4f96 GIT binary patch literal 23807 zcmeHvcUaTuwzV^k;#fe%2uf2>5l|5U=|rW8G?6GGLIg$;ktV$*Dhi4c20=PRdJut8 zR9YaTh>LzjZr%uD21f1l|%XzUAx$!?;cnucJ(Q2fSh~#*Y}ss?v^+r665jcl>CqT zyB!VfJGT+zzEiyUT)xk`Isv}!hZAzI^>+^hcPc38R|sxy6%6*Y*JyEn(a^(~pB2u3 zgqCv6_$zCLw%g#TFGj7bK+b9fNJY zi`li+)HE1#H4<}k{k`?6n<3ib($$+GPFo?TzcW3)E%o+EZJiydsYa>aOYf4tcLKKg zK4!lb?4>^J*c$CMruWv1Z-HFC7kc#mddyACuJxwJ_oSw7G;Q2x`W*yZYPa+~ZCI3> zx@iPdFTZ5use)tcvzd=td`7}Z8qvGdu3~`Apoq}V-%I#K7r_6(=4*PBeT zY zQOjF#&sL1jaGX6ML~|x(W+W%ycn8EpW48HM6GN}j+`>$1y_yTbekv3qL+G!3z;nfD z?sHnW7l~NrPkZ-Vje?c0OHxx3QFeXeAGn89XKtQXJRE<&&DWV7=Q-MHB%G79;$G1h zA8=8EEW2MeGeitg#2{s-_IJBCjOXpV7%){yo+zalQ*a#iyTqLQa#bt;@mKu$1z1BV zp0}T{$LZA{=p;0h+%A)kC9q0w4E_|N=E5F>QfuY)qP2(67B7CPO1D$wU%m?PTOsI$ z<}AW&8@!iAEy8?2=hH*q*oAAf5_4Q@4i=_28LQ=5IyYMux!PPPxKj6SbnFd}*jWAS zaDt1mYEKQP-axj@gYcZipm{?J+y>rH%=XnMaO#BQIzfi3}g>1Drq&YY4fZ>CvD;^MJ<0=w1%7%v3-PnLy=a%&lr9 zdLI_pHzY@ZOA4xy}!66<6J`?1fRHtbcI0ki42E zi)@mG1iRR+kT_Z-cOd_~?^LA#Se-}ExMt*#3|zmL(L)Q)GWlS>qh5uSc)v~WhSuya zY~68YuYN;VXV?qo{dEVB;_GYB_ufrs9YJ}~n|^VtK~I#?dS>ViNKK9D4-(`mNwguF zUTa?>voi?Z$y10RKDWcS=fb_mJ0DLJ4WMRv{3)LKRFao9yV*sm)R#K!Y|xS5QtsPt zj~c`VSym6LypB2u&WT%JHuuB0d!fSoF>r)0O-BQ+Q}j9Y0l~_fsQBWULrwHSV&KLs zG{VmtS2_78ohk2I1!H$l3|&26;^7dl;qMi%yL@oBfSm;d5# z524-CoqMF8e4l!IzxJAld!a|PbrQ7K!2Xv`z;8GIHtgRP-2V#L__o#li(3uP523ry zJk7~F1w!{JK8=}==`;{WW1SRlW2Xv#dasx{9_P0pUuQ$~JPP=89s zJkL-TJ9(l6gw&?&tmMwRq-u|(e-VeFv@6rXH9JMR{s3wHJus8B=1a(<4(G_UU33Q^ zMqP&$dX~&}I!e}6)kNLch2^jrktkZ`0G3|Bsg-XKw%Ga@d8O*n-bhr7;on?8V8jf4 zstt||q%{nrisQV=88OD#`Z-E(Z(UcBn;p%s@9kZOx_HINVfFb>LBvF*-T-&PRF6lZ z5+_MT8RtC^ri4l?y|Ns-4@6r!>*J~qg7?*&F7(OHX zkqkF57B3H*ZPr36&VmO~U{J~! zmm4PC?5^OAl!#H9(-GkwI9DO1;30^NZ25fuyASYTYRp1@z>o~tzn5XHl!Z%C<@nB_ zhJr_InmnzQu9^QjEh+vB^ZtGSqPEtctCgeurPqd8vZJ7I>X8h@Xj@%^lD8$UCxBYV z@4og=kW<#^pMs2!Lm3w0@5)PW!MlDYe zFe=iqD>9=0*{tr{LHl1kX#ac3^tWOEXNG<2Zt3I&7o^&eIh?zz&xNzg!PlesG+UA* zqx9H(MXo;q$KhBTw>?8%Bg}uKT#vtTo#O)CscE(H8;?xogg0@f!*MN@Z{Icq+U?nj z7@~0w6-Q1rmVFLwW6y{Rqy{{Au2o}i32Dgvly~H9%LfJ+!1|d?y zd}pwPINS|93UzB1zY*-P+1LE%HXV#qRLlg^JurXTJ%(oaHZj?I<>l@Tsm5w~!%OBE!ov`sj;K2U+O_ zN$FUrFLCH}knmc)l1+{{m_zsKzLoTntN13$GXV`V7sO7r>FClw;WWYvwXYfD@^0ij^_i|=`bL~9~K0ZEeqx|Ng!2`R)-|)PB z+#Y>)K)Km0E1a~!w#Il4BUotA*7tg$E{#JOK7apr3eGecOsSuz)cG6EDs|!&gQwY^qqHW!opDOi1U55>8gySo6!YL^UC|Fo|KMsQseK*n6gp zy|hQ1QbFq%3Wvl|dwI1htG;l4p>ayi`qf3UxBL6%bsmQH6mhOBxM3~Xp`npqSwwkB zS@|mSUDJfeZt!*Cv83!(~v9480DkBQr5iP z%*01_beFTg(~O~M^2}AmZ+t%M;R17Hwn&0cYSPztKEL>USx~dZf>CDi8dmfj7Ub(~ zr?d8UO?aen?Xq$Ax|J>yw2>9+Y0| za&jC$X_lqINU=(_^}81u8MG8&?}Hn$FZ< zj9|dei8nv_toU`mwzdvu+emCj9q=&0if8ST$H`L9v5!#g^#*!CZIR6=6bTxM5 z_>I(C{KsL2`4U!ZJr9^pb>UcDWC28<0AYuHVg#4bnyE5D94VWwmf@%17!#!qtoeCpyCe~L(s1Kxs-$nQ=C@5}$G>x8& zIWA%VWA;#3)(f3&<-L2_6VEKTY1g_itG0P7L9gV2GV zo-+R?3;U$U=khMbS^Mpz0FTw*p5)yVH(Z~T zz$>i$u}t$3)!MV=EIHmWFU}{4G>o<=bSA!g-nqzaM*y;Q3;AgjlZi#F|c3h_Mf|hF#cK7A8ZWiGV09n>a59Atn1ed$)Y*e;{k@-5W@I z_xRx$m*{S@_8)&YdO+5!`qp7(myb?`#OQh`hpCUBev!kZ_yJP9r0pLt%nmH$Qx!E) z3%&b?BV2+f#J0B~r3BfwhbNNPUwsT7Nge`$&%YHQIAkTY2BzR9-)?B4mD9@Z)22y| z<+hXUcHy2h>Fygf2Z`O-ZcL$T-`kg0>Hv4%5yYq2oP_^(db4KRvi^#KF0i0r zsm9lQu?r(P4h_i~68KGN84=K;>7CWT3DCB=LHrz*?@!Ryvh}#0pP$- zA<@?AK_&4OoH>f9K@Fw5vkrNk=16uyFo!?T`IM{?^r4wf$NVs1rH9+`qxraGYd>;E z#K8NhFea^509Wof=mVV&tB<*OL%*{;kkKypIN+`=9wkB^g>(D__R`Bk`-C!ihJL5O zksy8DCqfaCmKOE4jv3gbhTg;FZqzt1A;tohGcE^ ziZ|dx&zTNaW(=gL!Mp>}$3;e`vyRiH&Dgd`unafh6nDcff9PtMLk)rij}_KQkGZX( zbWQ0Lm%3K=omJaE+xXF?qBH!>_<5c}8xd5$Oy;Yogu*F@i ziXrdxKt?%pi!WeT8BivOiD2<71+uAVlW_IvlYY}xl1=uS)VPV{&^NN1gxSaKnfXg*~s$sb@GJW2T~Qya-*z%H8e8DaHwJ28Wo&j5R=(aV4nrZ z{fx6Y=fb*c+={4I=zZRc$I_*q5OZF zd77T%y%_*W5knTuQj*st;Zw>dX;en>fOsmdbMrybOmVL6SNm*xnmFau;}}V~Q{2E; zS^L@L#)KZS_bm?KSECXan?91Rw_ddplr(hGOk>_@K9~$=5%`HbKb3zs^;76Qo23z{ zM%oW&JfTxaZ~Wg~L#@x;$2~dw=Y^|y^;v@04&TZ0yKdhdp8ut=j|Vq9b$XzVuos94 zTOjf>9IH+aQC(2rOU8w&ElNn@E7Uq;-TCf5&_A_diGo3H5l9P(-vVAgWkyMfW;f5i z(-#4~w~+McLg#L&BV19l|J?}XH>`0hQcC(gv0EK`(ZSV%@QL-KW&KP zV+c+c0aT$+J92LguikRm7R2=TPKBz1yeukY;nK}GupEI%`x`pq(m#X@E#ePEy*nb2 z$`Q+-_|j91@}qHc24lxqqV}fcfBD3r55qH&vuN}w8P4aph^wFRlXE!}E>Coq>Bm=2 zv-_dWj26U3=Zb|0BsEN5O{xR&c>CgHEosQgynzbcw6UK1329lKC{G{o;X$YK==pkD z6Mw__P7C%Axr^hxBv2oIKUpBWAo6&@$pWua0i}2MS~;Aj<9p*@iZ~*!cJ~>2nyh)L z`}?cA5>#Od5B;OHM1#6sh#GOTrsazD@$-5w+zFHWXAkgvrB=9edHc$s%=bY`8niSV z-FGsR)F+2^KjWly{J{#f9A-a1Omd^i&MbXUrFW(qI+mMxRatoD#cYEIY`O{Q>|v7d zMwP9pnhD2Oi13%*Z=^hF4yh=T;R88^3~!Ss)!ksF(4J`|wuN3@0R!9gvO!as`QcN6~G-_bEQr-Pmyh`Ya;Iuw(r3ux+x&}$ASB~WB6;IIr!)J;MSk6>{k@F5ge$vZe?)hBdgi|fj&W30HfHzn+D^2=aAQcVHpTWd!%|K4$PQ0DVNxZsz&`;>< z@ZJ>OqYEBnr4~E`Hq?UrhX;_iTbH{vR3|Wk z)COyfrz@y~UBLi%asyw&6V1NkZk#1M2ADdJcczVaEu>;!8fUISH}#1aZkmBSN{-u9 zp(ZtJr|Ja*2hno3hr=G}>6V)nPNnf_yY=1@E$6o3e!Q?u6b52zrUf6xuk1kxmvR`~ z_j&tkE6CqmdB5tp;As?IFtZg?Z?9Ya*59PuKXTIic1SN@dS6ML zf4hz6+s(f)k03uoa9vicx3bI=ssj(@2_T(~)TCFLWSU$1UM3_4GUhTa*F<^{S)KUfvk0o_V`L zHoeOQr;+40l1=Q+Hf-}1^Z9gZ;ygmOp~@WyH)EOQ1EF7u#MIP>cK1VV!l7)Rctyu^ z-jLmk*=Ad*HzhgN9q2`w#qOlc)jYf&`7UL%tsXtTB%_4`*3WHqE?|A8-i-pKr6(t^ zMB2)|PLV&K+Rc<7ZOu(kKBxAT8N(KQyRQ4QU`LTgo-lRea;l z@ZMpE;(sA4|D|zh=bvPcc{uih2T;{`YmFT^Y!^Hp7JaVEC45m8 z12!2IVE%FBCXtm>3#0j2i#{Z-Fjj~dEhIn}^f>!jjbg0EKgjgh!DOJrAwQ>tfYf8I7g!1);HrfT!JX#oacYV!Swy{D6q zzHMsJLQg}C+I)!^E8rFU9ftgMJ_VL)jMOYhoQi!%+nDZUZ*qa?_SDT1H_`b@hUkVD z;a9q8(&ozpawqreQkKA4_`4JaASzum&m^FqpA6h?MqIzqLNS_AJR^jg5+av^Bq`mO zUIS39LDN`AK@--ON_cuUM_2SrA=r`=n!y3d*yd|K`drsi%fXy#bXOTzLD6D}nBE%q z>5F_gwKv*pwtNk)%AFYHh;Lq`6?o~tZUy}oL%zh2<%-m|(0%jYj-{K(e#IzT? z+m`@|g3GqmFwo2@bUKXXO34=g%i0i)_=*6XIT%$fSWQMXdro9Jo2kd0o* zKD6(JrgSm@Zz*w5x4*Y8{e`EzY~*PUL9y+k{FG`#9kjriSaRPEq@l~4{!LpTbS1Xf z{I5LwtZAlhfU)&5-*gBVYCOPzXVH3*NZa}rb9ho7fHn8qEXo%mR@=DtJn3>SJ(z@K z(<4z_L5GMNjk8ZCTZ>KnrOC+!7QkWjiqQ`u*#ULt8%6!co=;fcwRA4to8;B$U==X4 z{WmZ+rRqQVhNtwH&k`E5Lb7JbzVj0nR?{aF= zOR$)h9NIRCZMJN%ngo3tfX&GFpey?zk?U!4186}qkkQpEs^VNb_5qi|;o*D|OK(8T z71-fZ24z3frQbH8A6vdM1K<8<*hP(G6k_ z89`Z1P~t(Mol2RHg7)xKN@`Bsk08dp2PC>bK`JZph+A)EU$j)19lgoqJo^X83NO=; z37v7NT--JNc*Ic7MpB}C{ku_#;uOF0$h0{ifhf4u0t@-_EPvo?nm9b=Lj#8E=q|}w z9c1}_xS?$fysHtK!z49HgsVSF4w$Z*iE9YREX}f=H1ID!MQ~x2*x^yn0g&5E^X_)T zzauUMM{`QALEHoT- zzeW~^WuzwOiw~}<>Z<3Jb?kg`*}z+@0^~D2L>D>i9x0BY^^q3*saDyJYQCO?FLv^l zM_}q}_;59pAr;@eklv(A%jpDRCs^W1rEXWP3*`ayNt;KQo6=w59WY59Djs~~?7KB> zc_yt}XZogj`7i#x6*AwV)c=oB>Wi$fob&wWtD?Tm`L{X$&rJdzriF!qIWDba-Vc}@z^MU!Z^AX!+t<|Ue+C7qJT<`rqw4592!3KNhk)KwJ#rgzxITdD5 z8=%Nbx~KB7)29Ufjv%9t=<(j+BDN(JX)$c(GR%{H`3vU3u}5*qTxXE;{f|X% z`{^4N05VEkq*ZA>{x1FVDdkKkC?6$qYyW;TJ^)sZ4+5bh!p_w$G=?LhE{OKh>%9qi zR;9WqQ2i$XcdCKEM}UR*aPiIoK{n+xOD=V~fMzdyu22sJit(n))<78r&;)K#Ubu)^ z6*M6T2=MdoK1>)iJvVenBrE3+nLGvnYemJ~Wx5$#Gd6$S!wsR&a48F5$l{f~4k*F6 z)dMA_rJ&aAcS!?akU^Pk^c@fZD-Tm|&t0-%6g_}=fqlg~vl*Z$Zspx*+hXONx-a=G zZgvzUqW0dI6>p9Quu6pAAO|e|Kdi?C8x1e&|E%=FVdsr(`j9LQK*w>>pOsvCurIH* zJdMcNx#SE`=6VSLWYvw{Gn9MH1XwcepRWSedke(8)gt?=!JPO3NK(teS-*BkU$78i zdZ;FZFA~6^uUaL*M{ZSnV?1gi1@|tms{5+Xe>>a%bIeX)iwZbSD z`4>#qE%YhkkqqH=LDaQGuP!Gtz%OWzvB&1tWVY3k?&wOYL$mCYeTP3h!Z76xq7TG* zJX=v%XSWX&U6c>YtPR(gJMW!;!g`-)r$d%!O_<*XfkTF%@5PS!>?qNI$u|=LF6H#$ z^no&9|J1Ys_RmPvcrOmeh+EViK_>&I_wXlXPnc4V@{Ni3y6REv1yNrOpmb>{E!M^P z&yDGus84D8&9<29^~gVr*0nZc0y{2>>nYW7bM2Kv{;NcD72B9vD8E118$N&SBTTN z(H+|{m2DCz&8k4o^EJhk&tyCwIE~sT%{6^`R7+(U)@pQvV!s2(1t2ay`92!DMWc>e)O-T*jbYvAk~T#>J-yV!k^v;h>3n)=@HKkYr0Ygw3CbExz{lH2dwEjjtv2heYZ%g$-9abI6uAh$47PxjI;Na>>Z|H}}oJ+5KAYg(O zJ!(bzYmHET3#5?fWvL2ePe~E~p~vPW#eZnd`lq=k&{Ak67)mHz><;zz?uI4+fcMq; za-~0&-*6Mx@1^GMil6`?SXjloZuyRXe;*YZBI<|n55&lFxRx}4v&hPnlvMHF{KilV z`UArnJ3u!PMP@6wbv@7BN%b?66?{v!tbf!Viq5_r&~(FERKZ!e8fGf@n^P*-f;|I} zYI-ytwAhOO*IO3=(y)!?g`^JGEg>}4rWSfbf%h^F3BaUV04CYc`6JG=Veg+GKvv^w zeLx?xCNbt4F%S4O^=u|nmGk0I4LTn<;&8K$s7UPWC>O@Kp@6H(d#qi~YqSltFUwGy zD3Sopq5O%Xph?Fcs&Qa1WF|O|*xLGB?|5<9)|h<*_jib;d5BKe3~n-kY8(W8xPDr+ zQ9WKP@cF9_23sML)ti*Me~y-gYX-!ESiSzMkM$ZV)ZkEYx@Gda{mZut==F4X#s2wr zk^pLwPhTLCKWDk^kpfimp)VdeHEu+A297WB=SP3ms1J15|r!m%;}+f>a*tUwin01)uoZcXwtr>VE^^-OuzgeAs_ev$5BAjU2_*J4tw&%pUo`Zq2c#3`%Fft)VXJ|*;b{moj5H# zRXKMz2*mS>sNUftg`U23d%uiUB|t3W*5rhvPDg-+`7lt?6d%i&9|dDETTh=Ijd38B zym9~q$;AQm7b+f~f8Mlxy+r+;ANgyWv(4%NO;iWW+_m?%NEkMz>PQIbmi0b4zPjlb z8?6&-2*zzUKrO5h2vi)w>(mio&g#?Jp7K5Y*6CZrO&-JhuzU z24qv236jlJVM;`-KZCjFC~y;7U444XWnk3t+S7**7n_^SHp{vmO*@mHY%} zXjKAz(kSJ`-7y?O-o9P|OwNzOtB)K%yU}x`S+2J{aDy;%s{gK(Y3iNai>|P}atNl6 z(P%cEMs8=s?v@OMMO?(H~kmZWs0 zHue}tCome+0VIIlhaFGDfOr`TJo7&w^kAi{(nr9Y=a}ce7Q1Q>_I9S<>`1x%L*Mzy z6xL~Y@r}K%-KJ?-y(yD@S$w5Cm3G5+5t}2<1f^`n#K^)sb*p-d_QO7xoE>;_GiPf# z=>QAQ$jQXO~7jJ^Gl9x!~;@s%>90R_B@MG=+N;ZgWUc+ zt=MZko@ID-E=@07v`3{RD`(GZB!}(g3L8HL`cXM~-c38!h%uFLpZRR6_91<9nrokC zh}-!0KR?BZ!?1p{)v(+PEwu?s4QfXn28ZJKOG-OvJ2pmf zbCg>LIjQt`5Of!-_2<^tmTrIRmU7~9Ks{K3MxX$`4mj_}9Ti2TDb)NOTTiSxvRfqO zgoya2AEXTLsh(Qj-uLRpF+{1~?9;NN;Ua3=5jDUARGehdw4ikM@cx@uKOQ*+1LeWf z=}CdD&qC5%Q#fFWC(ON?AYT~GzO~05V8x>fSLd{8e#C~e@#9%LBEgt+k``a(86O0o z>H;&w>a`o!9dKotVLt8*{RMQ5>f)OOlU-(Kg4TSsy8?bf2Xjm{J1s-!Cfjpc$#%uS ziK5e64s|u1>;MgH$K4f0`+^PDK|b8^xU)Vi{n}4+A0i~?W^YF8&6&Xr4K53a^6YB zyzv_#(&5u)TCZ&?)-o=J={2Wna>rCyTA@9yjeR<$@vO*$4Up72d6@IlMvJ;L@4~jN zrb`u0OFl-IOiSKfpX+dsUqJe$wS-|CwkwxnlF|>(73)b~uns;6IJ7Mv z-qqNRIkww5Gh6B&Mm3_srC} z?YzG0?)t|;%JE0d(@3(&&}-`4QFFzd{xR}eF*q4MC#AhWb)UF8&l>jnSG!h6eBz&gx1q zaayHE-hs1*oO17A(IhTDcDsn!?prdhie`$uUc+kz5Ha-zmsoiP_-YJ z>!E}l476Xa#hB+?7YDBgyWzf-tb%=g;;(MIBDZaAw*R>Hd+92(9WSqJNqrqPE8E<9 z+rh~u|I;o&Bg%p9#RW8{$7`O3_iw-ED1Zaz2>hYubC{1OoC3>X`YBIxDP1?VU56dP z>~Lh2t=|V|>mQ>|>%7`fe(UAl*i%{V)Kv)t8>yUa2Tcleiax(;4ebj+gEeDobj2w*L=sOj}-C-_~> zabpEuSpC$$97)TNY$|OzO2-EaOReatB$=nfmy{St%K~x z0PCM^;mhWScdDZ=s#r_E3@NW>z~&15X%mxOt8Q`xQ@)=^OMrNLMk=z}U^Z-$O~`_6 z6jg7JMqRZ}+SB*Ls-L0jK!@;EtG4cjaeth=bNV~*W7n1wYrv12+W%MoNaxZ1zG4O` SRG-9sYJDAJ?YtA0ZvQ{p8)pUp literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramax.md b/Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramax.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fddf3c4cd --- /dev/null +++ b/Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramax.md @@ -0,0 +1,78 @@ +# Moving pictures from IMGUR to Panoramax: some thoughts and little facts + +As you might know, I'm the main developer of [MapComplete](https://mapcomplete.org). For those who don't know, MapComplete is an OSM-viewer _and_ editor, where contributors can easily answer questions, add new points and upload pictures from a POI from a cozy website. +Instead of showing all data at once, it only shows one items within a single topic, resulting in many thematic maps to choose from. + +Four years ago, I started with uploading images to IMGUR, a "free" (paid for by advertisements) image host. They were really permissive at the time, and I got the API up and running in about 15 minutes. +For the past four years, they served us well with barely any trouble. They rarely had outages and if there was one, it only lasted a few hours at most. + +But it was not meant to last. The first crack in this relationship was a little over a year ago. Igmur changed their terms of use, making clear that they would remove "images that aren't watched often". +In practice, this was mostly meant to remove NSFW pictures from there platform, but it was a good excuse for us to start backing up all the imgur images linked to from OpenStreetMap. + +The next omen was the change of terms. From being very permissive, those went to "please, don't use IMGUR as your Content Distribution Network", which pretty much is how MapComplete used IMGUR. Oops. +In [this forum thread](https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/usage-of-imgur-hosted-images/118806/6), I wrote _"I hope IMGUR wouldn't notice us before MapComplete made the switch to Panoramax"_. + +Famous last words. + +About a week later, our upload got blocked. Contributors were not able to upload new pictures anymore + +As such, Thibault Mol setup a Panoramax instance to be used with MapComplete (thank you very much for this!). +I spent quite some time to change MapComplete to support panoramax as backend, making uploads possible again! + +This has been notable in the [graph by TagHistory for Panoramax](https://taghistory.raifer.tech/?#***/panoramax/): +one can notice the graph going steeper during october: + +![](./PanoramaxGraphSmall.png) + +## Moving all pictures + +With all the machinery in place to upload to panoramax, I also created a script to upload the images from my backup to this panoramax instance. +I've been moving the pictures over in the past few weeks (before the divorce gets ugly and we get completely blocked off). +The technical details are documented on [the issue tracker](https://github.com/pietervdvn/MapComplete/issues/2189) + +But, by now, there are 39.124 pictures in our Panoramax server. At most a few (<10) pictures made with MapComplete had been lost by now. +The script deleted a few more image links - mostly in Germany - but these links have been dead for a long time - the original image was linked about 12 year ago for some POI. + +Ths can be seen when zooming out from the previous graph: + +![](./ImgurToPanoramaxAll.png) + +Even more impressive is the dent this makes in the [`image`-key graph](https://taghistory.raifer.tech/?#***/image/). About 39 out of 375K image tags were removed - close to 10% (!) of the image tags. +This means that MapComplete was responsible for 1 out of 10 images linked in OpenStreetMap. + +![](ImageGraph.png) + +## Why didn't you use panoramax from the start? + +For the simple reason that it didn't exist back then ;) +Panoramax development only started in [2022](https://gitlab.com/panoramax/server/api/-/commit/7217aa9b3aa5345cbc7c9532a4a174b9a20cb813). +It works quite well, but there are still a few small issues to work out (especially regarding some legal screens and missing tooling, e.g. for moderation). +I'm sure these will appear in the near future! + +However, all software grows with their users - especially if those users let the developers know what is still missing. +With that respect, I'm proud that this is the first Panoramax-server that is not related to the development team (being OSM-France and IGN France). +Again: Kudos to Thibault for creating and maintaining the server! And we'd like to encourage all local communities and other, similar projects to setup their own +panoramax server! + + +## Downstream effects + +Even cooler are the downstream effects. For starters, people who saw the 'imgur'-tags thought of Imgur to upload pictures to. +As such, some people started uploading pictures there to link to OSM because of MapComplete, but not using MapComplete. + +At the same time, other editors have been noticing this and are thinking of implementing features that were pioneered by MapComplete, +such as thematic maps (such as the streetcomplete overlays) or having image uploads too. + +## Support the project + +Please, continue to support the project! The most obvious way is to [simply use it to make edit](https://mapcomplete.org), +by [reporting bugs](https://github.com/pietervdvn/MapComplete/issues) (but I'm swamped with work and studies right now, so it'll take a while before I'll look to your bug report) +or by [supporting me financially](https://liberapay.com/pietervdvn/) + +You can follow us on Mastodon: + +MapComplete: https://en.osm.town/@MapComplete +Edits made with mapcomplete, including some pictures: https://en.osm.town/@MapComplete_edits +Panoramax: https://mapstodon.space/@panoramax +My personal account: https://en.osm.town/@pietervdvn +And Thibault: https://en.osm.town/@thibaultmol diff --git a/Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramaxAll.png b/Docs/Reasonings/ImgurToPanoramaxAll.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e1fa33b05118917e2ec479a1d40c8a2a4cbfabbe GIT binary patch literal 24927 zcmeHwX;@R|y0)#Y)FM!;0*VZ36%_#y5SbFGiYNjK3JO9PRAdZ;jG3xwML`4yKtV`V z29Y5m^B62L3z0F*5lDy-Ad(O=kl}mL?!7Cx&pG>?>s;6Vz7Kxb>&jZmTI*f!`@GNn z-1q(T=1I$=Qr~a-e#MFvQpd~=Td!F0HD$$$m219R1wK)D{SvZbh0Bg(hfPk0I!z8D z?su`1GZ38{yx&rJD|Oma?NZ_S@ma>-{ZxI^l6InF?qTD`>Yl-$v}c2^KfIUXCn@K6 zN9XQNttZI^2di%kj$h6-a4vbM@?FE3lh_|tt~R5LIo^-@#$*`56qe3ePLVZU{36qt zpOr$gCj?!vJ2iOEo%yghX#bIjRPDJam|&}L!j7<;kZtQKBa86sx%NtW559`;89w}* zT$85Wt+;+CbLA=z6E>-MAi$i@t%r(|tWF+!e-dqy(K_1nk1t6FtUb`MGW7hp$ycs2 z(hhrjuGX4pd@T{SB1SFB`0V5>7s*wIFAg*ud8Z=t&i`VbM3nIX?^n(evJ$1=ZKix> zl)GonIZq-&U4F89L`Ci@*65e|xLTz>bMIb!i&Z?knX=U{R^mg+%N}g4(&i%P7b~N% z=f9C=u28a*MZD<2*2u02cJ_~rsy0!oUcRZtBW09EM2=~XbI=S<`)_hi4>T%g+pp9} z>81Mg7j+?9Q;ZSqznfsKX|2gNq+G|2_iax*+MXWuf@DlK+}Y;Q`Rr6JjYifB{qU|# zobA92vdgiLzpOlj zVJQbg`fu9reYUT}-!0J~$kRY9U_}vq%$H0ad@+*8?0kGEVx*kZ+n#0~1%nS&l=Ahp zFTF97bG&lO0Lk@Z7p6-q8r(Msnz(zI#vdukzPEfWT7BcesW~M{2Z*3@E ze%}SNO?#aWvPnKmr(~fMVybYKgAsGaWyBw3I?5SU4i)>un3T>+1SgT$4EJbs3m5X) zx_G;6r^+&JC@)8oM?dj!UmBMdj~t}umTO2U8WfBLG97H0m+{DqO7$g^TwokB;D5C2 z-8IQbEhIJ0E?v+2hxU{H48lG{bX`6yzt9^9#gz9HY8r~yI0tG=2@La-;| z>TYec5d@l7O`oxIJR=lDmIl)H&lf5@T(r3Q`cw$Kv80ZA$XwoRlNw%U{*jrem78vn z)V?jo$a)Q5fMzr)=Nk3;r9d%ga2Ztv3V3(wqSEa!&IPRC-7BmvUhkzeZ!h;zZ~o=B zCnGYO?!!19$@NOv^-7QGWpC9>XS+}J71kmWoAG*0tjdcDktR+&wl3+s&8@C=#_BV5 z3h-1`t07*#>YVwIz4e%bt))eT06q?JpQF^2g)oN7NGN++o&-Hlf|mE~Xx>VCZ=si6 zUlj^5NRMXj2@AH;YEUDzl2M}fN1^rtlg6=>_)s1-A?lRi?ID>Bgj~UJv${jkX=sKZ zLbEw>{!lWHL&MvM4kfG3mx&%*7M>O9wF_WhYyCaGm^&bvn=-2+jADlUN9)plla!N% zhVPB}VDw(IeDdY&SQ1&!u^Eq^BhthS0#{Z1?Ln$I zo6MkJ;u%ixXmK>LFt=pnd$FsEF7dCCaS9cCv=Nhc5)I|{!wHU}So#?}*E}!*Z7O?~{*48#KsyBekSTyh^bZ(TgM7Q)wo`&f7}4G{}EO z?9*g2^k7kP)BX&L?2d$`TMbk`5xm4!nCLHO-2aOk(K0sqAE3DQAqgJHO*^63j841!ox;8Jsa zA|Fn!+5yXSQX++2&;+n0$Dvqb0lKiK`t=l{=n5`3&#gZ4@gM;sUbrJBjfOFK)>DZH zDdUbrb-Zw?X|Ib`=;+L}>EO|DFr=@;$f7L8bTg$G`f@vpoBr(Ff22QoQK-(wy^$+u)vv5@FaY^J*^hcqHp*snwg>BT&J4uJ6N`1 zw9>U9c8f>#FJE=RmOwI(*CwJkWuIdhmL|PPQ*P_3Fpw*y1B{X}qT@NATT^L5omy5?&LH8Vn+(0kqYP zv=sTGm8MkZapcR3;?{@?p51P)xq*DAirwu1GFFBqjd5Djp(tCvPmhcY{D^Oc(OVbr z%XRkEl@gv#3~=#H+Lunu5Vx7$G6R4rmluk*LWoeTu@*Hns_Ts187RSZdZ4rgJ!RUx zMR^rY8zHN1f4TynDJZj|8_hWz&%HA$ayANfHs<-r^VHWJgmbcZKnpyi@DPrDZPQ%Arxnj8R13ILe*}tyAR7X=v7fR4ECNO0^q}< z5y3ORG(mrO_bQR3aPIFYB~h&D&kMqJhfTf;pL`YO{VH^_Iy`u)FRlnqcH$WDN_|9D z9d8k&&dLUBF(0qRbtHYe!KPxjPeC0w7NE{>89^pq+vNb09ZdlzXK^+3Nx3cIezYtW3HlhS%)Tcz3%;ZRCb=7EX+u zQDUYuw29EK{rd_$JV2SCi?ka$=QsSvZ>j*#@YL1flo1c0nix@u|LAkr)A1PNfdY?v z(7BVUV}Ggi#Lqz*SjwGy2*e7e5diN1@o!0qnBAUm-Wtg37)s<0@LeS!sTk}r(*ST-FdkfzDye|6Diwbde4NlboYkV|1%VS&j6L4|Zju>DYt8f`<$BD%ZyN{fh%U}1 z7!+J}JUgF_uviQQqfoy=Ot(6(?7s*}z@bZZ0nL&#S;&D>*|+kPla7QbUHqGPrC&kk~{>E4Gid zBxT{W-Rf>#X*(j9Ruds(2lJYE`}k08$bkEQn;~H{Lmn@b%O~)vRw<7b>i86G>%Jl% z2d#7x9tLBD*G_b0Ma9sFUb`{LyKK_eiwExF5sLst9HU?fl<|)xg^#BtL^90C;q;s? zlIbn^JKy|wi+n-831h2xzn+aGATMPhs#NtF}Nv!3H% zS|QT|mk7bz=&>?b;zQ#oS@qpRq|@lZj36b%3nhe~lEYpl!xt%qUL;xgalxG4lg_zLzUwbS$Ipm0l!1xoIwDjaNY-qI4EI^9eGcR z2>_$)$7lOr2M%|O;pwzY`2|A75F{mPAxyYCc6jTJk-U)z#TsGkj4^iMV7_&!iZ{>fi5V7j-))LfJzwJIGBdim zK3c&}XfQuFW!{l)VQv^Qon2+i11N!IHR~n=c!~YOyojXzKFoThiPwK+eHZElFE2Jv z47odnrC>z72^!VK$nRbCNcoUs*_B4QDq5#`_AuZd|#QnPGpWh&>osqozmtfsq_6K{(e>mC5{e2~>@_ zL&!G1tt*DK0z4RqR7#KYH($Du-2qz->xnpsr0NJbH@(;%KsqT7fy zHIH>9_^M%^eW^Ho8H;58(Lzn|I?$kSZ_(DXEZ|s{x-5%=mX%8Xs;0~1z6r#yuW5ET zN%lZP|IS7Gu}+hUvX0N0var_lfo@f8U34RFC3t19X$zDuN=HbX#~rtt3VkXVHUJ6*%ICFzS-y%m1Qwdg z^^eHM4cUlJ=5MA%H!cddvnHa5bxOyY(IQVCbzQ)hlngdy^V8)Wg(RmWjk5Po7Sv9& zfKBN{8i@@EPG}`GcQ}!#W*9&*+obDxdZMq;Yhs`@aMLHCf|#2;hFvAK8|#o5Kz2PySR%I+}(C0%o%gE9x|7>oKCWlabgRBK%?a~Na-H*`Vj zHCi8oM@J8qhh#))RvnO1*uTeTphU|e*+4fLWP-J{qQyzh7HOuQjG_gM*B0-33m0YL zGy`Nl$yZ|Wj^#yT?0fovJedFlOrn0^C3ay;lAavQo!S&vi%-ySv=@L8(gHwd#E=~! zqpX28_8)oO2{<0t3cEEM_x&U#zxQ`Oy=bu-Ce@^hle2By!7KQ51ee`mmqvp@Pm2of z86;r^%w|o^DhCw1%Ps@F6+AzAdhDa%%NS560EQqq)3qU^`TqfNf^I(kW#Z)LjTH0! zgu9~ItmZ5?B(;dtglpgG?gl3GKL`|Fj=J1=Ka-icJL?`ABZ6lNr9THeN?NXmC&1XY z)Pn(s397yPJXcIeUSJB>p>yHq^mP@PgtYlbz4v73 zLzM`+(_)z!pwB!2_z1$|vS?$y#P#q~rNi{B2}rO3@z>SstO26$U{aftP{ETur-rVb z$=KJxTEd#Z2>)PBiUjaf9^o6;7k?A1#&;u|o32G`roRG{fKcIX5kB{ukSc?V?+9x? zE`nl2TGs)xcGrrLTkl>YU+nE^&W#nEIuNh`(9>3?9nr*fjPAs5BabiEBSNt8! zHzNfe9qoYe%)*~RPXb~^(u%vF7qbOC%iaax4>V|J2&Ns%h!T&E9hk|-mT&$l=E~7; z5R*buER`#L{P`J2F{eatJq(jgQpg>SXfN{)#s%76m==tL2!Q0Au;zyD9ET`!e(21| zgcnb9)h7Lb3lpFmFe4|X5LP@B;DVF}KI+brQlOgRBR>O~*-kOz4#p|0{IW&FF z#wf-oEKTrOyWJiDOm_s(mr@hDeqIDnJaSA#nec22m_tROfVt5t$0S#KbWwm^))W8V zth|ozmZy;ISxA1*R7@Hk!jED`v_8OAXe|=Dr0K5W{erPifj};Lgn!5!1XE2*BFt@( zO3~a)iaAf3-bvW}$5JiLGJ~|tAT2XU%XW%o2ii8$qC^DKv9(S0$1tf4@ z5d5APx*&`P_#z;if=vKt%O@8MxY)k{eEeg@b%$h(J113OWmi0A_zScRzU6_|Q|@g( zpd^xzWAM!eS9S(Xbna?-q@T~X7YTXv?DM5Bxk11O^7`gFn_}O=$QdWC3k|V4&egw6 z;Fk#I4m4m!4}(%3r7;sA7hOCs3FUAHfB=qE;glE7o>Jp*sb2o#`Ut9~g%C=EKVGEZYBTO+*SA+6^=!Zh=HNt3*c!ba!f(anKoYhn- z>Z(+lIq_ic7WQPXwmPh;qSw9t_BxEa=rFe8KjU7O7*e9(=Z@8id3xSGvC}{o=Bff^ zciPnA7ZAkAXxJKBar|kt(E@UaQnotaJ5Vw~>M4f968HPq_mu{^vkRMIjNjlePm~c{ zG_3faNVH@n!gde+4Kuih$ph-_1vfVYpyo)zhm3L9yL>=Oj&SxkRg{346?N70_U3a) zv?vP0gsnI&BJzb*zVTvC0~B8Y{6XW9YPlaYS6Q?E%JPh;#ApFNaYXnIP7nt34tajH zsFHG^!HvT3w!%Rw1uyLz78OR8wI0h_k7cdLvex5Y)p{)3j)ALtIe0Dy&wuCOX*Hhc zm3vIl;L5Ww)96iSLjECCngn`0!T;!aHZFh#{UbXMu*apmIR_9 z6=hK9?0eyIh~0RIcLB|_U<8n=(v%E7YHmj9s%#2N=dS&K!& z1qo9#4hp1X6Qs+UOB5v-cq|z`59lYWi5M|ArXvHw&YZxrN~S>pwhR~|qF~B@&Dr&n z^xzs*^Hl-VrV)~Pf`&Re8HNYiCDR2^(+;xyEPSEFqROa$EJ3e94X(z+Lb=#0qtSZl z#Y5p)0*^CcNO3n@X#3F|Lq8NDZGq#yR*l58!eNbWhy`m0t^*Jh3oOnE4v4hQ3(7JV ztoJ!ELe&_%sC97y#=H+~;qkH>=g;1HhnOx^4H|FXKIm5?MYYQ6D-VHdCDK}w>{xsn zgj2d;P#?ho;N^&HU9faOGX9?5$H;3v;qx}ka~SYBui_v@rppKYeD}5|M{4IYn(*@l zt!^^iZZfTIl67tp-TA;oF|uIaAdayZaE#8NZU}0SzLxl5xP~tJMsMX*hl`x{t@Kk^sR6N#k$GHD*U9o0J77@;eMwKD0D999pO-GgQIT$|~+%AV{i zRP!NMRZg?>d4fjA=5|7Mk1Z$swYJM2zjgv=N&#pqa0$0AdNQ4<{Qk|;P~ecD%4|S3 zA2<3Z){M?9WXQZbbp9Og(3uQYgu#N=3OUGBo_K?|<3<<+_5C$5UXVW#F(TH8j|T6k z^jI+iDWtytjpZK_s$$bJ8Gf?8+ zg>Q3OH0#qUWtf7w`_TD(sM>Wukt7-|=3tCkG!dCglv*xkioqFh^vpr6IymNndHCqt zHfBVP{!&F$YnKXHoRtr)(_TtkH1}?%%%hF}Ac!d%5~V{4i^No|V=A!HsltgE!z;1$ z3yaoRfW|6bDP^g+Pu~G6=)%G?5X$6f6}zZKA!2(tV0;6)zeQl|QCX4L^XkK&(`xbW zO;RuwE=t47xR*M{m7~$j2%^E#8#kw@D0ALv*UF3O^WAaKE3IG9TWpo!aU=Gp6UrDj zN8DqILCs+aZ_}wlX0~6QEf$w)pr$1hnv@MPzVIs6Vg(t9xioqPe)mxBhzek_B#9p&Bdce6&$~(d-iCt z;DC^k5t0Dy^!&n2fvOZHXm(JClA>GNe_Ax@6_Zh4TxBo1Z#(*hchY4d63`=_V^-2= zH1FMLi;*v!6K5j&BPpWebtzHS4f(20uEXKzkUHjg))zWlJZe(Ggx4#8;crHCr;^A9 z)}p=FzVN_TR_Q-n`f*wsR!~o@I*no+_|nnsSY+dvT{{jP6jsJm#@z4r##9Pi)-Qd1 z&GS;sLAYS|V3Bj+1h4jpN8L+WlX9K^QXNYLS%rw72vYK&jQBs?fh z7wn5)ddE~yr=&MabWnav>d=LSWplM6qQ5}(wGXJ^bQryzbn_Tl_?eAw^1o{x~CTbEwwg)7~wOH1_bx%&8rHaBpk zFT9ZJV2)A7X%lGaux(4HU_n)jrjpsyD#BxV3Ke%~=>5_qk^^tGnp^KCAhd@6VWRQP z=k>pWstAm6!@Px)wIF{h>43J+1J`5r&SS?Z)XUayLGYmG<>daFvgI zALNzEkNz!mjRY;pGyK9+kfP{;S_S#a&rF}0X3RJ|b-C*VIHnc7Jtpq~jY+W+?Hn?5ro`}h6XYmFjJ z<+#z@xglQS4;RoPa;6&ndN7)4rMYqbopu))L2iP{l6kGzY^Tda@Ybe0i+okoF2JRkbXY=io2{tjeY}i&6sXxb(b``K z$f=w}aqrZh!`Gr{R|w1@3k~No(#K(k19w}APNAvA$OpK+MI7V}6(Q`_zd?eDwCGrglemn|fWW9%HB^NCcuq%#<~dOD=2P`*aF)W^TYPc*vAoW3fMs_%eVYk`

mqKf@@rb-9IM!ot6)O^$|s}Njy?iPKuj93R% zFe|akfjL{sZY#r~+h=)XD~4|m&N4v5@V!v~vwnh>#kC!VnUMF;KiR_jxJNGObor!vKmvJtcCAlQB1#XLBXdG7Z}b`D~5WH`-Ge zmuNVmW0-l99l9V*ev}L&s7=jx0S1!3=214b)%de794)QYbb`c+>Wfpd5yX&=;BGrnmhjEAUJ|mXH9kP15G0R(X|8xkX+Q=d zI>DcK(o*YS%?znSpvK!~W1z?)L8d{ofbq>|Jr$n@W%uyy**>bcM|ovq>bpoN_RI)7 zPX=Nm=wccaFFt*Apm%QK)ht#uByAzHa}9+BHOF|N_YB)474>{wEw=o;_hW0cz~&Sr zfR4ayyF}E~IKGX*xi_LY>(R8Nk>ex9I0BMJ5cl7!?YClnCuTj&>Uau8lnOG>Ea?L| z+KKdPVbv;^yxCUHpllC<-hEL@6PJrKN7Q$z6<6Ad0(6&jLps`Q%o8Y#i_1{Q_%b0H zYNG0kO1)(J{HJ61r*M8n5M_{=aA4PxewKII;}fLUujJ2LO&`~T6y%L*4telTSB(lQ zgUXv=TYp{B$kJ?_AqsK~@}_aZ#l;v07^}l75yDeVd!)YjF$yA-`knO83N9L2;KTt8 zc-3e!PGED=-T`sB?Yqz0V@9{T(S{BMG1^**6Er8hLcjRKREF1(=UwrWWTUcXxJl{7 z>3okNZO!$7uN8K8?^N$ISm?rOWAFuOa1x)G`u855?TN+<(ZJW4Mw{MVxDvq)!B`7i znm~;A;3G$-H|V+{D4hMB6e6S>Vkz4E##+F zq2|+p#y0_a#{KV}#C$uWd+|PKM)_-XR8`evX&K|VU5dbw#teA^IP$6wW`j2%y)0!h zuaW?%Vp2|tYNQZNVtVl|Q3w`PvqAs5&x&S!fC>L-WNeC4OG2i%ero* z1+ctx>kR32lf7tD6z0(22jfBaYDci~gisq9L=CY^gFxVSNcaJBDP)Rl+naJqT;4X+ zb9JF|vd{%(^kb>)?_E&Fbd!yzf@2At6tUf0yE?v8D#|9T>VvS*qiGv73jtVSoRyw- z-4J6Vx3In))_UHN!|z4s@|xU&p1v%^#S9dcOk;@oLO~bGs&mbVgfeDFSzrv6!IWfoaF*Eu~F{aXz>F`$Y_fyvTi8U zrVMmm?C-iKBg}vb$3c(9R^g|b8>`VuB%T_SxV+v%LBh}6`}L3O_T*hlewKIW^)*Gw zNc@e+oxwktU#lCc-t>Ya{r%QpS2?dq#SIR7p52J-LA?5dg%XGLB0^{y39risELz1f zvc8vxx*ikoS5c6*H9+`aU_y~Q8=09#>sm|SN6&2O*+_~dR%BQbYQqpj7artrW z+Tj_qvckKV!;`LD29=RP}EH23Rf(8Y4Pzc?nwc+HPHDCp{Up0e=~;H)v{ za}Takon?1W#AvOPNMyy~BS$jXv}A*z?=z!wd%s#20Co1$m29rrvqvWI#hy3S0edCa z1?>BeK0ips%)Y;aet7LystdS?{#n^e&iW62Tdn`_m(}`f*RDNv<7}~S@=rhg^gf}{ z??l7R8{qHSjgN=cp87#+i|SVJ_x;u#l*0>uCijPb6#zx=#3>7)$Y+IGRt*c+`1H&G zVapZazEfr$qlxHGpH1qCG&Wi`%-l!^#~Nakp`H3GuZCH5?N&@vAJ4AHNGq_Tvd1wbgu_j54GFn54Jw*kStp`kgAE zvU~^F6PiFZcry;@dNcV&2asNytJ*ihro3yFdk7dp0qBquDW|CcLdIzr`xYK$*$k8_ zXB5m&oaiJ!5hodiy`(h7ncHTceN152_rNbm&r7jhkbghec=G4l_|silKZMp-d&W~J z7gkG3-UHt0X3#c?0-Vw>onL(&*8mj#2gRX@C%(^4>AM*0#~QQn7%0ihK9_GA6s)k{ z`{Y!uX!AQV0b>r9*-si8mKx_vRDkm3%rX5R!3+zY_#{nDMNq#wpiodwd5IIX_B z(hNJ$E%v!>PSdXgD+d^$RNn|BC}}3xRs4R;Ya8K(N37ez>*splCsn9B&zHQIrIUzl zzn@zDwk?P;UyD@lJz2l+{w}r8Z1*SU?@*+35%D3b%wjLAQHA6^xvSslHVAlwE)*2WeL>%3>banuF?G_~YMp<{f(=QTiX`^QeB*rp zEhy;(9&09Om({(NGntpZyT@FES4e4NcUN zIJSMd5g0BMNnji`H|#!rvJrY0xq~t-tz@)wgPQGqVD&Hu^?fSnjCGrnQ>J(6jeJ~5 zKDlAjq~4oXXzbVO_00*IX`qGG?pXVitKa^j=hK&JurLwJzO@!UdW2k^{YxFT&BXAV z>);&y+*ABu#!$}m6p(Vw7T-S}w_D%T(7wqb~%<6Os(4r>=brXpq@WcA0+9z0ln(SkaA$0 zX#h5ZPOlx5lr1+?_Faq&kA5i8sb$z%3H&$B&rUt(d~ghzzSD=n`r;?T2R8- z=9_J64{m=;Ftvqq`TF|2O=p!M$em#2-3RvRXMx$}M>Z-R@T+DscDe0+@=IZ!t+3lA zIpE$7i%zdwPe$_1L`E~~&*sg^ns1r(`W_H4svt1t1{Un1hn!s{qqGP3U+nO}_(1oc zl{3LK$E#21eywKeJxPCd=oM&Z)%89W90>D_l$p>u$#wd&5nk1t{T>IQn_Y;~k`tAq1kiT_iz z2P6621%?+}L2J6sN(--vwO;NynMc3r2J6!h>U_`Expotze4$YU`DP}{Oznm11^FKY z9S;2w)qO87nhOJpe!JuS(A7`+E%KWs>fb9 zyLZzK4;T2=4R|e!ipy3ems5NwiF zn%YF#N>KD9|JH4D+eate*>?;jyC3&uRJPf^Fx?#VNNC#aOmLB%Q&?}Nzjx%lEHeT`i)$=oQ*^NrIzC%>MG|;1CBV>PkS<@_GcA(beI~ylroXp zR&W-Yg?WW#%kT2eef6Enk4L?VjlSNMzG)_O*ZruBdOH`Ca{5hUIMJ6V7DKTlw0q1aY<%T{5@58!{Cu;SPe%fq=pJ74=hDVS!> literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/Docs/Reasonings/PanoramaxGraphSmall.png b/Docs/Reasonings/PanoramaxGraphSmall.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..705376585e5bc7b192b1791dd6942fd10c8b096d GIT binary patch literal 15315 zcmeHucT`hp_pXY{*uWV&l>#lp(n*0$shjZTZo_D`{Kl^$1 z=I$vw%T4Q*)~{HxVw1Ji@iQw{tirEYu~PB7wZNIo3ft=|Rv4#QA3x?8?#Ucj_ewPc zA)c)uyZQT9I=eSHySoP-J9X^zZyx(g4$N6rJlkp@7l_*z>ymuN!11`8dE&lbZCuV; zZCm}mfwld{YOC+8x2^tV+fPMCDAO$yZBeNCC;jQ8cGJ~igRBW2=wn7CZ2E~VbUfq| za-#pVYeEH_O`ocw1lTBq71XjCjBBTB7#&S$R+}-aCE(TPJHdfa_wq}&p^Rc2CeD~@ zYcTL=04ZS7hV3{*(Xy9%JtO@?sffiqgOC~l3vUY1b~AMhC4v@58DoohF#_(O;f_Zl z0v?teV)H3w8VJ4tZP*Rhf6XRzzSST;%h9QMFnNgN}QGOXx5bCc%dJXkTBbytsvO<0%Y@_6B!wtv`MUH#_21K2!DY+E5 zNoR(kyqDX}kwHf8`Qum$?=86%F=Vh7iP*UYzh1~WB{}ie0WIW^A&rx_b^LmYu6%xT zyK>A!iOf5hd8E3kj^Rb?$Rl;VaPVucHM&I1M7L&{;w7iYTb_`fnaBAy*B*8*Is3#m z_2=!V_SC_ivC<1ou~GGxMY*_;h{@czp5_9lLSI}+-~pGH+YGF0qH^Qo^0ixM)3xjg zbrJJr)j<57 zXj=w(t|Y!GPGLg(QOB5vI()V+iZ@4|(~1va^myxDYI)yN;^AIf+-wFduJEitc2H`L z1nXHd%%Mj*DK&>HP>-!U#&(9>Lx-8gQ-dRnf_M0Sc(|)_%nTHNWbXac3wwlb==c*T zIT53ve=>41JC!r!MK-(VBWr?Qd5-+H=gV<)f{&~Y2E?`aSP^q~i^ff==lZYKQ3MPL z7zVHo)#^32Xw83bkZ)R83a_~u`5NZ%#iBzv$z}ky#XHGY)#m?G+vuN%{8wK0&vN~< zTtJNd#~J?zbo!>Bz;cHc`3$TyzFtlOfq%ilhQyoHz>#;}IaOCk57}=v^D9d8nrja& z+;XoA5A=`djmf-flYHQXCX4>5u*a#;xjQ)waRAbA1abkX7Ji2WqgtNmYEZ9tj(Mmi z?Y8}hu}yb&A7tyCe{<^!fSCZcs=!O1tJZm*%m)DSEP~z5gSYdoVT?JKS69zBc$QR; zr;+_VR66tRiM9{5)L)E1!L7|-;PTO4hq**8b$Y3INdV2UxbLgtLmp(<#O%R{O#Sah3bJ=P!>d0__ zZP$7eRD$lQ`dF$X4t1)*0kq<#ayEOBqwS$9QaLa6z8wESv>Fl*GLLDjX@tqH`GdUv zdv*n+3*Z}6wdMGhI@f>u%m!roDhV6@5B58RyWObG^IQY$+3r-u6Fe#o8&B0bl#A>Xv+CKAogL|bh_EbMwAhC%ght4k2DydOy?Za=GlCrW z-uJ&Xv?6}uq(>rgzTW3;^1?XsTVozXP89V&&{Dhl->&q|b@(mG14`rkwzc?(AzaL= zKjn|Fwvb$rQcP?wjA&2_8<;=J-z6opJl$2c=4!SHWi0;dIjqFzpDhcnU4m1NuKLEJ ztw+ipL0mH-hVeH=mqS*6^C~Luts-q0z5W|BY~y-Vz`c-Fi>dSDmsqRtz`8H9l{YB} z1Nx#+G6VZd?q-d-Z=9j1aGBX(x&EK~x9{p})|gGtnyICW{QHJ?diw+I`FYVlEbj$9 z3~oK0>|XAmU8|o(p1C*jF4q9J^_$m%W(~m5NYP>*={yx}H0hvRCI9VfKlg&6EJLVs z%`5iu+C`~n6YFMr74qR*Y2-m^q4O&I+arHdsd@^zpdsZg{K5XUfZoOW`Co$9pWeq_ zg@oY+4Z;JgSG#bx?1K;cb$n9Y@OoK6tkkoSmD*$=y^v|@=M?|BQkla0vHZqr%)CL;jTQl-CQ9!xQsC3nr}G zK*K1u<$;DECs@Ra=@|%t@prw| zT0YiZ`FXaM&S|CDzSaN61(q{~rjFUVbr7ZULnp&l;F;3Mn24{C@uy0AC2~d}x@#~B zyJ#%g(2cc=cT>hT_ql2 z^I|{EVC_Q5K)5}B*Up;6n~-HC%;e$4irMBl!+LGO$H%-$-)~Gbmg?1(o?gFHVa>}o z$^dzr^KPqdSbh%%aYa*WHtdJAx5DM|1hvR3RaB(Fo6%ET{#NgVa+LNxKxw@M2)xe$ zML5+Ih13t|e+6j435G%A7e@#QSU>|vJ>+vn-=AC|IlXSn?u)w6wjxc|uuIuR>rh%= z$~bJw3ZUAr`1Hbg_A_>pM6bU3`At;)*`QWEKp)V*bim~yVt8tQSwg0sRwTU?&rGKZ zUYBchH&pp~eSEZ+XO#ko)$MVfkM1k!6$HMr@F$h+V%*Nw&4lMY)&hj;LR;0MFRFCq zi)g2sy224a*&sR>yEy?OKq;V83yZ>Q>f*dQF}9?eYc`bKS2pMgV9b4T`l(oAl$#M#GtheHT^oe-^ngNyeeb)E zkN20$?|1G3WOVMRhUpU!D}vaJ9=g+<6#m@>vQ(#9+J)csYYga-4)ZmkLR!63t!&ED z!TFZ`HJ4Xcy!pG(Sa3e*3M&KRx@EZ;%_Xhk-3qQ|i=u1-9WwKm(Zv9e^?dKLo?ij-l>J%5)5)tHgsyH5m z5BG_0drQo477Shxo}1gm!|O8ngYdzdKyLi^G+Ml()^>4hDC6Z+kIAiRUQ?-Foijn% zF5S_%ydayln&x<0FRVXlDG7+IK<53|ywk!639DxeDp?R;&DE&9Qa6GH$n=1b?1B{( z1BBnT&`HIl@+71oDE-<1{|ZSny+fT+y%{jpIXQeC_ol7Y6ugGZ*oGOf+Q{A`$mNE(?p&LekRpd4wrva#3hdRA_I)JVyksUdNCf$jkC#8IQVjDS|urM#O++gk48ah zH$$H0a1}L{#_3aqUMZLI#i7pn5xinVII}W=q!hbcB~kf+&~uJZo*yvjRdVYi!cGM& zHPIHIk3gRE-`99M2t45;aqbRCP-9-F+GW4L%>(w+XE1c9!<7JHI91&GagfWNC5Z)X zkI1fF!F3DG;I0{0RiY_St6P*C2~r3^H5gC303)ceZCXajBW@-=bBBfa#ck;K$;B3&NB< z|NOGJR2P=3ROBPOQ}b)K`meoRKJ{Fk*mk-G0C)E1kOb{}AM6^!k<22@yS}D++}i+M z$vuB9=6W=-?zAp0+M0)tE4;hJ5=&iQLkSWerUp+<`7tYEw3cI_00rz$&noC#VL^07 zXMF~7?-j#_)9RuSTt3DS@3CANu+QoZtKTVX6nc&QVkJ$b9}~#HM0TnteWQ}h{sGCV znYhuQTMiQ}Es&L)_{#iLP0`BeVLba?C7m?LFNyA}+q*v*98g^^{FA|a5&OSz+82p; zs0%xbW3v<5PaG@22R~lr@D`EV%ZbM!VQ!nA;ZqR~%tfX5leZgTf3g7yi~l`RDV-1w zUYh_JPM5gUl(33?W}zOPfuCqeepUm6*?U*)wbD*g5EuDr+eS|2EqniZAwB4#L#nUJ z9Kl|RD^wR36)J;0lqZU70$Eac8}Wygk~;b_H6G>(VZ%g*t6@M^&>L@(UZw+(QIi2$$NY7#!3A>3GkF%ANpkBxL3g&)0fQTD z^K~5wspj>Iqb1)M*A|&961e%3 zt^5nYDnVQXLH5!`N%|?=h+XpSv-&cRzpwO(S!2;1iXW=tSeEPl82|`u%EhYX6>|eS zwI#d#-x>}iU3d&szeV=Mt7=;`&L)||h$`}~Y_RO&NNv()N@JB2imw9(;z%Xt_ z31;7v7(e3ov^#trr{N8~_e6PoOv^I}%Fi*{vdmkAjgBnVDH@EYN+{$T*Zy8a5F?9T zf3Ac|%I#FE`NGxy^5S8m!;6g{vqT753if^e?x>MDZv-?@;s*=vzx)y1{$f8SLP+1) z*paZthEUy!%N!_Jmhf|rDfdBqG%@u| zWDqHSBN`ZlwBH~X-*){=7suZhQNZ=6oy}CiNTW>*W2T|nE-q%iIt%%T&hi?ia_6bT z7s3uLFJH-Q#2ZDY-K_8t0{Q^Y)l*a&BP^Q6;o9mwD$m>Sy&{d4zb~09YQ0%$=w>Pj zg*^s{!l<`>oOpztQi^z^Xsmp=Xd3N4Z7-%}$}In`yO0U|*{LhkB;3;7!7wzaT((%E z;1DMVL&I<~mzP`GPgZZR<4qV;-T_t1485Gt|C z&tJEW)+e?BkE*jC16?IL6HR!x(5CLfa)=$7pLlM603~DaaogIzwY>mt#*Tq_(CxRU z#oKHh$jEXM&Gq^DLeEGC)lH%Zy(X&LRZY>Q`|3A{^dA`1h3Nckv3mCk1FFTZl@7)Q zw%6%ZHuG#pY`l_t+M=8Z$MQWM*UwgPp|G%EIn()Jp5Gib2%xIDVTBrBLE+!xsll_E z^f!T#gy}4N?pl)neFrU9H)ETES!xaxssTA-Di(v!2Kj9wD;dwn{BXzYE2{ll*Z{I@ z1K423{U7u-w5j~Pt0+qTy;J~ER{v*?{-s|85K+SbIwP`=>~s2NGm$C?9;{Dy$l^Qp zY#7nQM%ac^+2~$#1R3B*w))T7|D`M)++(TdEeVSpCuMbYP0s?Z?=?Kg6OA# zYOZ=hWdBGR;mEj-q=RT_PFs91a?(sa&Gb@0#i>%wtf0lf`OcUYv2axq`7ae z2g2}Xk}GMp=m7o#4X7C}NPjF7^ReQOo{KfTz|ho4s$g)+bZNx2qseTLV;A|JI+LuW zQn0-2eP2$vZ-!#_N1xJvbdmi%dtWXyTMk8*X;sty9{99x&fjtoSZ&LWCdx+P55Sqz z&{g>3z^Cg;Z9$NyENP=J3#Up_g@~9j8BtIJMAePeh6Z)O-lJZ*P9a!}>{c?Gp-% z?$}{4A=8wXWcp#e4XvDvpGUJ=WRA=3yrAm6w z0z5Ie{pqe-Q&ztWNcPOQaVDMUf(!8Ayo>=Ipq^&6#CvU9jIit(D>;#6{M?_5U7};l z0Bs`I02UU2*r*`%H8uoFOmF5kXuaA7kwLB#2Gp`pVu9fm4%rVog~N;d;X(El`?JG4 ztTo02PQ?o7?@|wXpWv{uD3E$Isie-{IOss_%$p76F(wPyq(n=#C)f?eTZ%Un@6=Sj zTz?A^R!12Oo@(E)5)|JJSHefK>cfa5i~AwG6E%nJKk!oHzLTguIsEMD zCW{hq3Ez-RV=xM@x4+9Z{c+nl6Z+|dkAs{loHwHvOO#DDy1Eqvv_tU9d^#~>V$EBO z8$F7Z_$3Cu4Q0nKu!NxADMBv_m^cXMSIZ+ijOSZ)%QZ}9?~=j*zI}(@>d6v_IYtR#a66`2W z0oM)7lO{~XJe4*+x=S^zKe2uS#QK1@RGur(WEYtnkY}91*ETG*Cm@44(_why+Qq?0 z0do3O1+eLaf%UWRl;>r4iGcy-1Mqfv7Ld#6TmbN-Y}(_DC*oB<)pJ#3Y&j&W;;SA}IEdCib3cWQTy{*ByWtw?uBHTxr^~!wb!Td`AE#E=c=z?gJO25 z9uHQuTlb0>(H8WE32$K^p8TLSLu;wdJU~QD2MHQ5K8TH$!u4XZPSkulwIyZXTC*mP z<014eyf9HzxYnqVz9!xCJK;=>X-n8A_?5>;bI{FwrCtJLL#7vBQL28fV*_&!l1+uT zU5+UvoP~DkH9fbIwqPFBu3zYg68S)$Mqk8cogZ`+`l6mPbJv%!5UfaE1E6)T+gRaO zQoS2uK(?m_ciL7eBuc%;%9QaHC(vP@4YJ)3l`fsjku!ye`0LM;b^v|R9|EuTxI)9043pD!WU3XX0+(Hwtx_}8d{i?hEVw`pBnwBFW@JijF5Aq3xnO89;^j3NP8 z=VN*6vY+{@+7CQ|fO^Oibi)^-PN0ZCpLDWY!Mp~~AE@-8LFtPf95A9(XR|`}$UvK; zO5`D@Q`)JqXN10V3{t^=Bu+uQjhRDmAt;RQmp( zHhEl1H45=w&~P1NBDzXsO)?zV-1i_oNlt)X_^o3hRQaNnu@dMtmW~3dZ5HZ z1{Sgz``XeR@!G|WEP8jLAoM-Cbn!y>z+ttzI2>W#4zy^QYy&tWqx~_9a@Pn?`uO`Q|Q4xJ8+12<}_aA_5 z!8SngrRJCC<#%mUa#ZCgCx|Oo+J$!qS{!bl&$+yfxP}Rd^Kwco`N2_Q;dR=3Zv}7c z3UbgMd>l_*bMFyS9i-Nc=j83z=Vt;^{HS;!YeU*}5(i-v%J7Rt9A~@aC=iU2Uhs`G zjf84p{eish0eb&=j{y-7Vkiyb9+BqK{bxDxM*FDF-A6q}9h1ghP7IDZgE9gc(hMu_~4G-KwEEeRn61 zZH+G|K3jcIoVF?pFk@1{HfbyL_Z@{t&}Vw1orJ&=%G2D3 zpMst3Q(ni~oZpLNe_Q~7&7Yc{5qnytrP8xQBNGFi?1nk;GZ(D$%NuC?fycDRIhiNB zZPZp}XcfxI8@~vKKGj{>w6ecgR`2X=A@wviO5uRZ1NF-xK3YxK(3eKF+0jLz8=Lf> z?LBBt<|#mV6$tvAONc;CM&imDB_LM^wj3*Ht;B?G^FRs2(A11GxY%G|D&=xJHu?g^ z2QtTmp^S|eKA8o5rvSBndN$KxVm6uQK4bx_6))e zR`bv)Hzc36*Y5hl#7+MJjr*(cITWzqqa}*5d*IY*GI+A6x@5J}Y~e^HQnr}kn^xlr^4a!WLE9*#>a1WtGpu_X zY)j6ZbZL#*R9+eebUD)o735S^nW(V2EB1uO1HXV@8!+(eU27p8ui=|3vKcEikLH5? zyAAXCeCwp$Y*ARECr@su+wNHY49-a&pO%@eTIRV)UV334lC8@=iUP>UN1*=n*z~;t zH7aPSb}|^>0k_r=GCmaSRkE#SwXZEeMLzF{+cBWcycf5xk5Ke#DvxD7Vd$IQ)9cHR_G||elQ+hk5z35K7yDaK z&Qz|#yCu|QJQrj4?|WM;hlgjU4uiE@aJM0^%^8+fpL*#n<5yY3aoQzJn?nVZ_|0j< zU}D@pq#p60=%-t9crq%V+a3569^o!f6xqQ8pH0vt^g`Aa>+st-VoXev%^Pqbfe+N_QRe*+P>)O6ziseUtu~laW@7-y3BEKPOq?L72H0tNd`(3T3Y@Yk zcJ*OR%2uSH_T)$dbkA&|)D5kas1arAdloq4azr2}uMs;QAWt*DG3^&ZHiJ{UuD*kn zc6P;Wdkk1-mq%I=rWp?SE@rc8YUL&lu9MdE#V$;lD^5b+%nZ)~NR)@L3QUrL;Y z!Pit7G0#8!l1{yV1MZZpx5-gsU8j$%(G9TU$;jtO*zA(rfV96s%GqnyRR8E2+l?_k zvNCw`(TeXU%Zdjd7lR*?hYo4Hc=hPamC>}mlIW*x*J$@3?D=a0v1ihXmg2+ec2ad{ zkMD(Y088z*SHLmW?fh{P9S^&S{fdDI1CQT&z!vn9i=?%iEeYeEU=v|w0ZgFnMJAQ#{4tFf~8Cf?S?H7I2NKh zmF;YhU-HsE(dK z&{Y+m-;_>T5Y^z*OitH*wq;y+3JdRah4`bI@{exnGM^5|>E;pCK088lDz&YtGZ@`Y zBgMQeB~8kM9f)7gW{2ea9ES^I*M_A3Si*I3J704k_i>SGY1=#BU2?3GnravQkGP#D z@1@-Xvz?;dPoLQDWN%SV|KW#}2IPtMXOZqz6(>*ghnj|PA*Th$Yv*^H4dhoB0wI1iA-Q^VjC(*jll79+rd2gr$AAG9B2 zZmvL2>R>%Pt}WVb3KKfp%odjaXw;dP@VR~7BJ28W!(u%#0P03ei|!jgR#hBp`wm&DRUz82>Sj_;&VxQi7U!w#NH0O%sdMQx)S*H&X?|ny#}0L5$e209UeNhD zQ%l}23k-U{mDY5gZEHkUzf3IA zm6-JDq_$P-?cEfBod8B$IFo3Mbf5f*%VaH*dJrA*X13{{h+SS-p95qTMnC{k)!QDn zL7zka~B3{5NT2bu}}qy}XnlCju9m~&Eo9=BFE3`lDH2XOn4Aws!nw(wI81tk^< zN-jHg3hpk{chfeTM_1W82IPCBhF&Eb*65}j3O9WJiIb-)0?1-h@a#*gtd6JX=i?e@ zlGRV%#-VMY+e2nLUZ+)|OMa-qw~-!`8@ILtT5nh&d@Kj71%K?`LdfN;!W(Crv>%7L zeIi8<=Roh+7?l?rrWw6;uRl)d2BfttQE~Y(k*NKqe_r`1xao~?MQ3W*QTI+)1N5ez zT|TYd-Tj^(xA&Qt*2dj{(3=`rT6QU`Zs~aR>|469u2O+JFdMwrW?nUhLP+21G2FFF z2ShAz0QzIKW__2QYE@3RAoEkriivzpt(^`}N=AK*G6uu4n>%WJ&mhYE6{PT8z_2@j z5B=m&%CEo&C~)io4xhEHM&1PupX>hL{Bx&RdX3WA>vAJX9N?dIS6G|d9WVLi+|B<5 DZ)jA5 literal 0 HcmV?d00001