From 875b3a3ea89d0c1bc2afb20f82193f0b618bff9e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Pieter Vander Vennet <pietervdvn@posteo.net>
Date: Tue, 6 May 2025 01:45:39 +0200
Subject: [PATCH] UX: plantnet shows better error message if no plant is
 detected

---
 langs/en.json                   |   1 +
 src/Logic/Web/PlantNet.ts       | 984 +-------------------------------
 src/UI/PlantNet/PlantNet.svelte |  16 +-
 src/Utils.ts                    |  25 +-
 4 files changed, 47 insertions(+), 979 deletions(-)

diff --git a/langs/en.json b/langs/en.json
index b640d56e12..3dc1f0f98f 100644
--- a/langs/en.json
+++ b/langs/en.json
@@ -738,6 +738,7 @@
         },
         "loadingWikidata": "Loading information about {species}…",
         "matchPercentage": "{match}% match",
+        "noPlantDetected": "No plants were detected in those images",
         "overviewIntro": "The AI on <a href='https://plantnet.org/' target='_blank'>plantnet.org</a> thinks the images show the species below.",
         "overviewTitle": "Automatically detected species",
         "overviewVerify": "Please verify that correct species and link it to the tree",
diff --git a/src/Logic/Web/PlantNet.ts b/src/Logic/Web/PlantNet.ts
index 769fb60c9d..bd8b258ea6 100644
--- a/src/Logic/Web/PlantNet.ts
+++ b/src/Logic/Web/PlantNet.ts
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ export default class PlantNet {
     public static baseUrl =
         "https://my-api.plantnet.org/v2/identify/all?api-key=2b10AAsjzwzJvucA5Ncm5qxe"
 
-    public static query(imageUrls: string[]): Promise<PlantNetResult> {
+    public static async query(imageUrls: string[]): Promise<PlantNetResult | "no_plant_detected"> {
         if (imageUrls.length > 5) {
             throw "At most 5 images can be given to PlantNet.query"
         }
@@ -15,974 +15,24 @@ export default class PlantNet {
         for (const image of imageUrls) {
             url += "&images=" + encodeURIComponent(image)
         }
-        return Utils.downloadJsonCached(url, 365 * 24 * 60 * 60 * 1000, undefined, true)
+
+        const result = await Utils.downloadJsonCachedAdvanced(url, 365 * 24 * 60 * 60 * 1000, undefined, true, 1)
+        if (result["content"]) {
+            return result["content"]
+        }
+        const errResult = <{
+            "statusCode": 404,
+            "error": "Not Found",
+            "message": "Species not found" | string
+        }>JSON.parse(result["errContent"])
+        if (errResult.message === "Species not found") {
+            return "no_plant_detected"
+        }
+        const err = result["error"]
+        console.log("Get error result:", err, ">>>>", result["errContent"])
+        throw err
     }
 
-    public static exampleResult: PlantNetResult = {
-        query: {
-            project: "all",
-            images: [
-                "https://my.plantnet.org/images/image_1.jpeg",
-                "https://my.plantnet.org/images/image_2.jpeg",
-            ],
-            organs: ["flower", "leaf"],
-            includeRelatedImages: false,
-        },
-        language: "en",
-        preferedReferential: "the-plant-list",
-        bestMatch: "Hibiscus rosa-sinensis L.",
-        results: [
-            {
-                score: 0.91806,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus rosa-sinensis",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "L.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Hawaiian hibiscus", "Hibiscus", "Chinese hibiscus"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus rosa-sinensis L.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152559" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00759,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus moscheutos",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "L.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Crimsoneyed rosemallow", "Mallow-rose", "Swamp rose-mallow"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus moscheutos L.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152596" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00676,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus schizopetalus",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Dyer) Hook.f.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Campanilla", "Chinese lantern", "Fringed rosemallow"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus schizopetalus (Dyer) Hook.f.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "9064581" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00544,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus palustris",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "L.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Swamp Rose Mallow", "Hardy Hidiscus", "Twisted Hibiscus"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus palustris L.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "6377046" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.0047,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus sabdariffa",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "L.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Indian-sorrel", "Roselle", "Jamaica-sorrel"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus sabdariffa L.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152582" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.0037,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Abelmoschus moschatus",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Medik.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Abelmoschus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Abelmoschus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Musk okra", "Musk-mallow", "Tropical jewel-hibiscus"],
-                    scientificName: "Abelmoschus moschatus Medik.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "8312665" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00278,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus grandiflorus",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Michx.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Swamp rosemallow", "Swamp Rose-Mallow"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus grandiflorus Michx.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152592" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00265,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus acetosella",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Welw. ex Hiern",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["False roselle", "Red-leaf hibiscus", "African rosemallow"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus acetosella Welw. ex Hiern",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152551" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00253,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Bixa orellana",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "L.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Bixa",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Bixa",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Bixaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Bixaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Arnatto", "Lipsticktree", "Annatto"],
-                    scientificName: "Bixa orellana L.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "2874863" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00179,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaviscus penduliflorus",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Moc. & Sessé ex DC.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaviscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaviscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Mazapan"],
-                    scientificName: "Malvaviscus penduliflorus Moc. & Sessé ex DC.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152776" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00145,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus diversifolius",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Jacq.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Cape hibiscus", "Swamp hibiscus", "Comfortroot"],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus diversifolius Jacq.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "7279239" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00141,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hippeastrum reginae",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(L.) Herb.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hippeastrum",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hippeastrum",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Amaryllidaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Amaryllidaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Amaryllis", "Cheryl's Treasure", "Easter lily"],
-                    scientificName: "Hippeastrum reginae (L.) Herb.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "2854474" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00114,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus martianus",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Zucc.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "Heartleaf rosemallow",
-                        "Mountain rosemallow",
-                        "Heartleaf rose-mallow",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus martianus Zucc.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152578" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00109,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Acalypha hispida",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Burm.f.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Acalypha",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Acalypha",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Euphorbiaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Euphorbiaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Philippine-medusa", "Bristly copperleaf", "Chenilleplant"],
-                    scientificName: "Acalypha hispida Burm.f.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3056375" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00071,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus arnottianus",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "A. Gray",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Hibiscus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Hibiscus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malvaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malvaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "White rosemallow",
-                        "Native Hawaiian White Hibiscus",
-                        "Native White Rose-Mallow",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Hibiscus arnottianus A. Gray",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3152543" },
-            },
-        ],
-        version: "2022-06-14 (6.0)",
-        remainingIdentificationRequests: 499,
-    }
-    public static exampleResultPrunus: PlantNetResult = {
-        query: {
-            project: "all",
-            images: ["https://i.imgur.com/VJp1qG1.jpg"],
-            organs: ["auto"],
-            includeRelatedImages: false,
-        },
-        language: "en",
-        preferedReferential: "the-plant-list",
-        bestMatch: "Malus halliana Koehne",
-        results: [
-            {
-                score: 0.23548,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus halliana",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Koehne",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Hall crab apple", "Adirondack Crabapple", "Hall's crabapple"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus halliana Koehne",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001220" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.1514,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus campanulata",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Maxim.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Formosan cherry", "Bellflower cherry", "Taiwan cherry"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus campanulata Maxim.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3021408" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.14758,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus coronaria",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(L.) Mill.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Sweet crab apple", "American crabapple", "Fragrant crabapple"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus coronaria (L.) Mill.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001166" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.13092,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus serrulata",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Lindl.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "Japanese flowering cherry",
-                        "Japanese cherry",
-                        "Oriental cherry",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus serrulata Lindl.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3022609" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.10147,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus floribunda",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Siebold ex Van Houtte",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "Japanese flowering Crabapple",
-                        "Japanese crab",
-                        "Japanese crab apple",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Malus floribunda Siebold ex Van Houtte",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001365" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.05122,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus sargentii",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Rehder",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "Sargent's cherry",
-                        "Northern Japanese hill cherry",
-                        "Sargent Cherry",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus sargentii Rehder",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3020955" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.02576,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus × spectabilis",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Sol.) Borkh.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Asiatic apple", "Chinese crab", "Chinese flowering apple"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus × spectabilis (Sol.) Borkh.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001108" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.01802,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus triloba",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Lindl.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Flowering almond", "Flowering plum"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus triloba Lindl.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3023130" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.01206,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus japonica",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Thunb.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "Chinese bush cherry",
-                        "Japanese bush cherry",
-                        "Oriental bush cherry",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus japonica Thunb.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3020565" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.01161,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus × yedoensis",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Matsum.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Yoshino cherry", "Potomac cherry", "Tokyo cherry"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus × yedoensis Matsum.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3021335" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00914,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus mume",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Siebold) Siebold & Zucc.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Japanese apricot", "Ume", "Chinese Plum"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus mume (Siebold) Siebold & Zucc.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3021046" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.0088,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus niedzwetzkyana",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Dieck ex Koehne",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Apple", "Paradise apple", "Kulturapfel"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus niedzwetzkyana Dieck ex Koehne",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001327" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00734,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus hupehensis",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Pamp.) Rehder",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Chinese crab apple", "Hupeh crab", "Tea crab apple"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus hupehensis (Pamp.) Rehder",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001077" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00688,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus angustifolia",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Aiton) Michx.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "Southern crab apple",
-                        "Narrow-leaved crabapple",
-                        "Southern crabapple",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Malus angustifolia (Aiton) Michx.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001548" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00614,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus subhirtella",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Miq.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Rosebud cherry", "Spring cherry", "Autumn cherry"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus subhirtella Miq.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3021229" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00267,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Robinia viscosa",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Vent.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Robinia",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Robinia",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Leguminosae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Leguminosae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Clammy locust", "Rose acacia", "Clammy-bark locust"],
-                    scientificName: "Robinia viscosa Vent.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "5352245" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.0026,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Handroanthus impetiginosus",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Mart. ex DC.) Mattos",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Handroanthus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Handroanthus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Bignoniaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Bignoniaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Pink trumpet-tree", "Taheebo", "Pink Trumpet Tree"],
-                    scientificName: "Handroanthus impetiginosus (Mart. ex DC.) Mattos",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "4092242" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00187,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus glandulosa",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Thunb.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [
-                        "Chinese bush cherry",
-                        "Dwarf flowering almond",
-                        "Flowering almond",
-                    ],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus glandulosa Thunb.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3022160" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00162,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus persica",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(L.) Batsch",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Peach", "هلو", "Peach tree"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus persica (L.) Batsch",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3022511" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00162,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus cerasifera",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Ehrh.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Cherry plum, myrobalan", "Cherry plum", "Myrobalan plum"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus cerasifera Ehrh.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3021730" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00159,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus prattii",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Hemsl.) C.K.Schneid.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Pratt apple", "Pratt's Crab Apple"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus prattii (Hemsl.) C.K.Schneid.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001504" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00159,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus pedunculata",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Pall.) Maxim.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: [],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus pedunculata (Pall.) Maxim.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3022277" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00153,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Cercis siliquastrum",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "L.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Cercis",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Cercis",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Leguminosae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Leguminosae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Judastree", "Lovetree", "Judas-tree"],
-                    scientificName: "Cercis siliquastrum L.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "5353590" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00128,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus sylvestris",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(L.) Mill.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Crab apple", "European crab apple", "Lopâr"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus sylvestris (L.) Mill.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001509" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.0012,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Magnolia × soulangeana",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Soul.-Bod.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Magnolia",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Magnolia",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Magnoliaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Magnoliaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Chinese magnolia", "Saucer magnolia"],
-                    scientificName: "Magnolia × soulangeana Soul.-Bod.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "7925303" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00118,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Cercis canadensis",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "L.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Cercis",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Cercis",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Leguminosae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Leguminosae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Eastern redbud", "Judastree", "Redbud"],
-                    scientificName: "Cercis canadensis L.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "5353583" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00114,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus × prunifolia",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "(Willd.) Borkh.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Plumleaf crab apple", "Chinese apple", "Crab apple"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus × prunifolia (Willd.) Borkh.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001157" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00111,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus serrula",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Franch.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Prunus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Prunus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Birchbark cherry"],
-                    scientificName: "Prunus serrula Franch.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3023582" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00106,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus pumila",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Mill.",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Malus",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Malus",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Rosaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Rosaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Apple", "Paradise apple", "Kulturapfel"],
-                    scientificName: "Malus pumila Mill.",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "3001093" },
-            },
-            {
-                score: 0.00101,
-                species: {
-                    scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Viburnum farreri",
-                    scientificNameAuthorship: "Stearn",
-                    genus: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Viburnum",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Viburnum",
-                    },
-                    family: {
-                        scientificNameWithoutAuthor: "Adoxaceae",
-                        scientificNameAuthorship: "",
-                        scientificName: "Adoxaceae",
-                    },
-                    commonNames: ["Fragrant viburnum", "Culver's root", "Farrer's Viburnum"],
-                    scientificName: "Viburnum farreri Stearn",
-                },
-                gbif: { id: "6369599" },
-            },
-        ],
-        version: "2022-06-14 (6.0)",
-        remainingIdentificationRequests: 498,
-    }
 }
 
 export interface PlantNetSpeciesMatch {
diff --git a/src/UI/PlantNet/PlantNet.svelte b/src/UI/PlantNet/PlantNet.svelte
index 818dcd7e47..7ef4259fcd 100644
--- a/src/UI/PlantNet/PlantNet.svelte
+++ b/src/UI/PlantNet/PlantNet.svelte
@@ -3,7 +3,7 @@
   import Tr from "../Base/Tr.svelte"
   import PlantNetSpeciesList from "./PlantNetSpeciesList.svelte"
   import { ImmutableStore, Store, UIEventSource } from "../../Logic/UIEventSource"
-  import type { PlantNetSpeciesMatch } from "../../Logic/Web/PlantNet"
+  import type { PlantNetResult, PlantNetSpeciesMatch } from "../../Logic/Web/PlantNet"
   import PlantNet from "../../Logic/Web/PlantNet"
   import { XCircleIcon } from "@babeard/svelte-heroicons/solid"
   import BackButton from "../Base/BackButton.svelte"
@@ -28,7 +28,7 @@
     undefined
   )
 
-  let error: string = undefined
+  let error: string | "no_plant_detected" = undefined
 
   /**
    * The Wikidata-id of the species to apply
@@ -47,7 +47,11 @@
     collapsedMode = false
 
     try {
-      const result = await PlantNet.query(imageUrls.data.slice(0, 5))
+      const result: PlantNetResult | "no_plant_detected" = await PlantNet.query(imageUrls.data.slice(0, 5))
+      if (result === "no_plant_detected") {
+        error = "no_plant_detected"
+        return
+      }
       options.set(result.results.filter((r) => r.score > 0.005).slice(0, 8))
     } catch (e) {
       console.error("Caught", e)
@@ -61,6 +65,12 @@
     <button class="w-full" on:click={detectSpecies}>
       <Tr t={t.button} />
     </button>
+  {:else if error === "no_plant_detected"}
+    <Tr cls="alert" t={t.noPlantDetected} />
+    <button on:click={() => detectSpecies()}>
+      <ArrowPath class="h-6 w-6" />
+      <Tr t={Translations.t.general.retry} />
+    </button>
   {:else if error !== undefined}
     <Tr cls="alert" t={t.error.Subs({ error })} />
     <button on:click={() => detectSpecies()}>
diff --git a/src/Utils.ts b/src/Utils.ts
index 5df75124fd..27fbddef19 100644
--- a/src/Utils.ts
+++ b/src/Utils.ts
@@ -879,7 +879,7 @@ In the case that MapComplete is pointed to the testing grounds, the edit will be
     ): Promise<
         | { content: string }
         | { redirect: string }
-        | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number }
+        | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number, errContent?: string }
     > {
         let result = undefined
         for (let i = 0; i < maxAttempts; i++) {
@@ -917,7 +917,7 @@ In the case that MapComplete is pointed to the testing grounds, the edit will be
     ): Promise<
         | { content: string }
         | { redirect: string }
-        | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number }
+        | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number, errContent: string }
     > {
         if (this.externalDownloadFunction !== undefined) {
             return this.externalDownloadFunction(url, headers)
@@ -931,12 +931,13 @@ In the case that MapComplete is pointed to the testing grounds, the edit will be
                 } else if (xhr.status === 302) {
                     resolve({ redirect: xhr.getResponseHeader("location") })
                 } else if (xhr.status === 509 || xhr.status === 429) {
-                    resolve({ error: "rate limited", url, statuscode: xhr.status })
+                    resolve({ error: "rate limited", url, statuscode: xhr.status, errContent: xhr.responseText })
                 } else {
                     resolve({
                         error: "other error: " + xhr.statusText + ", " + xhr.responseText,
                         url,
                         statuscode: xhr.status,
+                        errContent: xhr.responseText
                     })
                 }
             }
@@ -1010,8 +1011,9 @@ In the case that MapComplete is pointed to the testing grounds, the edit will be
         url: string,
         maxCacheTimeMs: number,
         headers?: Record<string, string>,
-        dontCacheErrors = false
-    ): Promise<{ content: T } | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number }> {
+        dontCacheErrors = false,
+        maxAttempts = 3
+    ): Promise<{ content: T } | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number, errContent?: object }> {
         const cached = Utils._download_cache.get(url)
         if (cached !== undefined) {
             if (new Date().getTime() - cached.timestamp <= maxCacheTimeMs) {
@@ -1021,7 +1023,8 @@ In the case that MapComplete is pointed to the testing grounds, the edit will be
         const promise =
             /*NO AWAIT as we work with the promise directly */ Utils.downloadJsonAdvanced<T>(
                 url,
-                headers
+            headers,
+            maxAttempts
             )
         Utils._download_cache.set(url, { promise, timestamp: new Date().getTime() })
         try {
@@ -1060,15 +1063,19 @@ In the case that MapComplete is pointed to the testing grounds, the edit will be
 
     public static async downloadJsonAdvanced<T = object | []>(
         url: string,
-        headers?: Record<string, string>
-    ): Promise<{ content: T } | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number }> {
+        headers?: Record<string, string>,
+        maxAttempts = 3
+    ): Promise<{ content: T } | { error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number, errContent?: object }> {
         const injected = Utils.injectedDownloads[url]
         if (injected !== undefined) {
             return { content: injected }
         }
         const result = await Utils.downloadAdvanced(
             url,
-            Utils.Merge({ accept: "application/json" }, headers ?? {})
+            Utils.Merge({ accept: "application/json" }, headers ?? {}),
+            "GET",
+            undefined,
+            maxAttempts
         )
         if (result["error"] !== undefined) {
             return <{ error: string; url: string; statuscode?: number }>result